The Islander Menu

Welcome to The Islander, a charming gem nestled in Shelter Island, NY. With a menu that beautifully showcases coastal flavors, this eatery is a culinary escape. From the comforting Country Pot Roast to the tantalizing Islander Cod Tacos, every dish tells a story of quality and care.

The lunch offerings are equally impressive, featuring the mouthwatering Lobster Roll and the delicately fried Flounder Sandwich, perfect for those sunny days by the beach. Don’t miss out on their famed Fried Chicken and savory sides, ensuring every palate is satisfied.

But it’s not just about the food; the friendly atmosphere and welcoming staff elevate the dining experience. Whether visiting with friends, family, or solo, you'll find a cozy spot to unwind. The Islander isn't just a meal; it's a delightful memory waiting to be made.