Hello dear
Welcome To The Islander
At The Islander, nestled in the heart of Shelter Island, we celebrate local charm and hearty flavors. Our story begins with a dedication to serving delightful favorites, from fluffy pancakes to mouthwatering burgers. Guests like Rachel rave about our Western burger, often considered the best around. This quaint eatery captures the essence of “un-Hamptony” life, offering a warm atmosphere, friendly service, and a menu that rotates with local delights. With options like shrimp tacos and fried chicken, alongside friendly outdoor seating and dog-friendly policies, The Islander is a beloved spot for families, friends, and solo diners seeking comfort and nostalgia.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
Country Pot Roast
Bacon Cheese Fries
Tuna Fish
Chicken Salad
Grilled Cheese
Fluffy Pancakes
French Toast
Turkey Sausage
Home Fries
About
The Islander
Welcome to The Islander, a charming culinary gem located in the heart of Shelter Island, New York. This delightful eatery can be found at 63 N Ferry Rd and boasts a welcoming atmosphere that embodies the spirit of East End life. If you're on the hunt for a spot that serves delicious comfort food, you’ve landed in the right place.
The Islander’s menu offers an array of mouthwatering mains such as Country Pot Roast, Islander Cod Tacos, and Broiled Salmon, as well as local favorites like the Shrimp Tacos and Fried Chicken. Each dish reflects a commitment to quality and a genuine appreciation for simple, hearty ingredients. The feedback from patrons speaks volumes: one customer raves about the “absolute BEST burger” she’s ever had, and another notes the restaurant’s “warm atmosphere” and “friendly staff.”
- Signature Dishes:
- Fluffy Pancakes - A breakfast delight that’s sure to please any morning palette.
- Crab Cakes - A perfect blend of fresh ingredients that burst with flavor.
- Baby Back Ribs - Tender, flavorful, and a must-try for any barbecue enthusiast.
- Customer Favorites:
- Fried Chicken
- Shrimp Tacos
- Burgers of various styles, including the famed Western Burger
- Desserts: Don’t miss the delicious Apple Cherry dessert that rounds off your meal perfectly.
What makes The Islander truly exceptional is the ambiance. The decor is bright and charming, creating an inviting space for families, friends, and solo diners alike. The outdoor seating area, which is dog-friendly, adds to the delightful dining experience, allowing guests to enjoy the natural beauty around them while savouring their meals.
If you find yourself on Shelter Island, The Islander is a must-visit. With a menu that caters to various tastes and preferences, alongside ample positive testimonials from satisfied customers, this restaurant stands out as a beloved part of the local dining scene. As one dedicated customer put it, it remains a “consistent part of our rotation” when on the island. So why not give it a try? You may just discover your next favorite dish!
For inquiries or reservations, feel free to reach out at +1 631-749-1998. And remember, they operate on a cash-only or Venmo basis, so come prepared!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ We arrived shortly before 3 and they were nice enough to let us in even though the kitchen was about to close. The absolute BEST burger I have ever had. I got the western burger and it was incredible. Service was friendly and fun. We loved everything about this quaint, local “un-Hamptony” spot. Brought me back to the good ole days of East End life. Too bad places like these are disappearing out east. ”
“ Perfect . warm atmosphere friendly staff ”
“ Always good food and friendly service. Favorites: Fried chicken (so good and sometimes runs out), shrimp tacos, buffalo wings, burgers. Nice outdoor seating area and dog friendly. Consistent part of our rotation when on the island. Cash only or Venmo. Strongly recommend. ”
“ This place is a delight. The decor is charming and bright and the menu is excellent. We had omelettes and pancakes and our little one had chicken nuggets and fries. The salads looked super fresh and big, and the burgers did as well. Friendly service and conveniently located in the middle of the island. We will definitely be back. Go here with family, friends, or even alone. Many people got take out while we were there too. ”
“ Went for the first time today with friends. Really tasty meal and great service! ”
“ had a nice BBQ burger and fries ”
“ Needed some lunch this was recommended to us. We had a very good meal!!! ”
“ The tomato soup was the creamiest yet strong tomato taste I ever had. The shrimp taco was alright. ”